Cory Salisbury — Salisbury Real Estate badgeCory SalisburySimple Choice Real Estate
(801) 245-0511Admin
Buyer Guide

New Build vs Resale in Eagle Mountain: Which Actually Saves More?

By Cory Salisbury

Modified on

New Build vs Resale in Eagle Mountain: Which Actually Saves More?

Eagle Mountain Is a Buyer's Playground Right Now

Eagle Mountain has over 50 square miles of buildable land and a dozen competing builders: Richmond American, Ivory Homes, Edge Homes, Garbett, D.R. Horton. That competition creates real incentives — but it also puts pressure on resale homeowners, who now have to compete against brand-new homes. Motivated resale sellers are negotiating like never before.

The Builder Rate Buydown Math

A 2-1 rate buydown drops your rate by 2% in year one, 1% in year two, then returns to the note rate. On a $450,000 loan, you save ~$625/month initially. Cost to the builder: $8,000-$12,000 baked into the home price.

That is great — for the first two years. After that, you are paying the full rate.

The Resale Alternative: Permanent Buydowns

On a resale home listed 30+ days, you can often negotiate 3-5% seller concessions. Direct those concessions to permanent discount points that lower your rate for the entire 30 years.

Example

  • $475,000 resale home, 3% concessions = $14,250
  • Buys 1.5 discount points, dropping rate from 7% to 6.625%
  • Savings: approximately $190/month for 30 years
  • Lifetime savings: nearly $70,000 vs a temporary builder buydown

Hidden New Construction Costs

Model homes include roughly $60,000 in upgrades not in the base price. After closing, you spend:

  • Yard and landscaping: $8,000-$15,000
  • Fencing: $6,000-$10,000
  • Window coverings: $2,000-$4,000
  • Basement finishing: $35,000-$50,000

Total additional spend: $50,000-$80,000. Resale homes typically arrive move-in ready.

The Equity Angle

Eagle Mountain currently sells at $150-$175/sqft. Lehi and Saratoga Springs run $225-$250/sqft. As infrastructure improves and job centers expand, that price gap is real equity upside.

So Which Is Better?

Neither option wins universally. Compare total ownership cost, not sticker price. Contact us and we will run both scenarios for your specific deal.

CS

About Cory Salisbury

Licensed Utah Realtor helping Utah families buy and sell homes across the Wasatch Front since 2014. Cory specializes in data-driven strategies, buyer negotiation, and new construction.

Learn more about our team

Ready to Put This Knowledge to Work?


Whether you're buying your first home or selling to move up, we'll build a strategy around the data that matters.